Exclusively Pumping Breast Milk

I read an article about “The unseen consequences of pumping breast milk” and it seemed like an unnecessary controversy. Providing breast milk, whether by bottle or breastfeeding, is an endeavor worthy of our support.

The biggest benefit is that you are making breast milk and your baby is receiving it. The process of lactation is important for your body. Human milk for your baby is profoundly significant for the development of the baby’s gut and maturing immune system. 

For the record, I need to correct two points in the article. It said “She’d had as many lactation consultant visits as her insurance would cover and couldn’t afford the $600 per visit after that.” The fact is, her insurance coverage, according to the Affordable Care Act, should cover breastfeeding support, supplies and equipment for as long as she is breastfeeding. Here’s where you can get the facts.

Only one insurance company in the United States is actually covering (no co-pay) IBCLC visits. And whoa! What lactation consultant gets $600 per visit? Not even my IBCLC colleagues in Manhattan get that. Check that facts, ask an IBCLC about cost, check with your insurance company when you set up a home visit appointment. 

So what are the “unseen consequences”? Apparently there are three concerns:
“babies are fed too much, given milk that is an inappropriate composition, or, worse, contaminated.”

1. Babies fed too much.
An article in the Journal of Human Lactation suggests bottle feeding, whether breast milk or formula, is a risk factor for more rapid infant weight gain. I didn’t notice any mention of ‘paced bottle feeding’ in that study.

Exactly how babies are bottle fed is important. During feeding, it’s crucial to watch a baby’s cues. Holding babies horizontally with the bottle perpendicular to their body means the milk will flow faster. Babies will gulp and consume quickly because they have to drink fast.

A more sensitive technique is called Paced bottle feeding. This allows a baby to cue when she’s ready to feed and when she’s done. Holding her in an upright position and following her cues allows her time to suck, swallow and breathe. She’ll drink more slowly, it’s easier to see when she is actually finished. That can make a difference in ‘overfeeding’. Here is a link to a video that shows how paced bottle feeding is done.

2. Inappropriate composition.
Give your baby what you have pumped, it’s that simple. Human breast milk continually adjusts to what your baby needs as he/she grows. Mothers can write the date and use the oldest frozen milk first. It’s all breast milk and it’s all good. For a baby who receives pasteurized human donor milk, the Milk Bank designates preterm breast milk for preterm babies. That’s because there is a difference from milk for full term babies. This is for premature infants in the Neonatal Intensive Care Unit.

Speaking of appropriate or not, human breast milk provides growth factors that help the maturation of the baby’s gut membrane. Human milk is designed for human babies. Formula does not have the growth and immune factors of human breast milk nor is it rigorously monitored for nutritional quality. Is formula composition appropriate?

3. Contamination.
Cleanliness is always important. Wash your hands before you pump and prepare a bottle. Wash bottles in hot, soapy water, rinse in hot water. Keep all the utensils clean.

Store breast milk at appropriate temperatures. Here is a link to specific guidelines for storing human breast milk.

Formula can not be left out at room temperature for several hours. Here are guidelines from the W.H.O for safely preparing formula.

One question was “Would the availability of efficient pumps make it more difficult to argue for the importance of legislated maternity leave?” What a curious bias. There’s more to maternity and family leave than just providing milk.

Parents deserve the time and patience to learn about themselves and their baby. Parents need the time to learn this valuable work. Paid family leave and positive, informed guidance makes a difference, especially if the family has had a rocky start.

We agree on this point: “Breastfeeding is about more than the milk. Babies don’t just breastfeed for nutrition; they nurse for comfort, closeness, soothing, and security.” With or without a bottle, you can still provide many important things. Cuddle, skin to skin, paced bottle feeding, listen, talk, make eye contact, read.

These ‘unseen consequences’ are irrelevant. The value of human breast milk for human babies is profound. Give credit where credit is due for the good work mothers are doing.